Morris County is home to a variety of pizza options, each offering something unique and delicious. Whether you’re craving thin crust, Sicilian, wood-fired, or a local staple, you’ll find something worth every bite. We’ve compiled a list of a few must-try locations and what people love about them.
Mama’s Pizzeria in Roxbury
Mama’s Pizzeria in Roxbury is a new spot started by two guys from Brooklyn eager to share their mom’s recipes. People love the grandma pie here, noting it strikes the right balance between cheese and sauce.
Reservoir Tavern in Boonton
Established in 1936, Reservoir Tavern is a Boonton staple where you’re bound to run into neighbors and friends. The crispy crust is a highlight, with one reviewer stating, “it’s the kind of
pie you dream about.”
Millie’s Old World Meatballs and Pizza in Morristown
In Morristown, Millie’s Old World Meatballs and Pizza gives you the option of wood or coal-fired. People have their own opinions on which is best! Can’t decide which cooking method you want? Try both!
Woodstack Pizza Kitchen in Pine Brook
Woodstack Pizza Kitchen in Pine Brook serves up pizza using locally grown and
sustainable ingredients when possible, and offers a seasonal menu. The burrata pizza is especially popular amongst reviewers.
Columbia Inn in Montville
Those in Montville and the surrounding towns know that Columbia Inn is famous for its thin-crust pizzas. Many diners say that the thin and crispy crust alone is worth the trip.
Coniglio’s in Morristown
Another Morristown favorite, Coniglio’s, is known for its commitment to high-quality ingredients and a dough that is crafted from a unique blend of flours. The Vodka Stracciatella pizza is a crowd favorite!
Jimmy Tomato’s in Denville
Looking to expand your pizza palate? Jimmy Tomato’s in Denville offers an Indian flair. People love their Paneer Tikka Pizza and Tandoori Chicken Pizza, which use traditional Indian flavors. It’s a must-try for fusion lovers.
Each pizza spot adds its own style to the art of pizza-making. Next time you’re in the mood for a slice, consider supporting these local gems. By choosing to dine local, you’re not just enjoying a meal, you’re helping these small businesses flourish, one slice at a time.
